While the perceived benefits are often met with mixed opinions, milk, and yogurt can potentially be good for cold sore prevention and recovery. This is especially true if these selections are consumed when you’re experiencing the initial HSV-1 symptoms.
Although natural remedies of any variety can provide subjective results, milk and yogurt are popular because they contain lysine. Regarded as a potent amino acid, it became a popular cold sore treatment prior to OTC options appearing on the market.
In addition to containing lysine, milk and yogurt can help to boost your immune health. Maintaining a healthy immune system is a proven way to prevent recurring cold sores.
Let’s explore the complexity of this topic and equip you with the best information to make an informed decision.
Dairy products may be able to reduce and prevent cold sores due to the fact that they contain lysine. While both selections promote positive immune health, lysine is the featured winner.
Lysine as a Cold Sore Treatment
What is lysine? Simply stated, it is a valuable amino acid. WebMD describes lysine as a foundational tool used to make medicine. As it relates to cold sores, it is likely more talked about than ever before due to it being touted as a cold sore treatment. Most medical and health sites note cold sore healing as its primary claim to fame.
Whether taken orally or applied directly to the skin via an OTC product, such as Super Lysine Cold Sore Ointment, it is found naturally in a host of foods. Milk and yogurt are just two of many selections.
Although research is rather inconclusive, many people who have consumed lysine have reported cold sore relief. Because yogurt contains a notably high amount of lysine per serving, it has been deemed as a natural cold sore remedy.
- Both milk and yogurt have been branded as potential cold sore healers because they contain an amino acid (lysine). Greek yogurt, for example, has become very trendy due to its immune-bolstering properties.
- Some studies indicate that it can reduce HSV-1 outbreaks while also shortening the period of suffering. However, medical experts also believe that it is unlikely to stop outbreaks entirely. As with all natural remedies, results may vary.
- Regarding fast healing, it has been noted that combining lysine with herbs and zinc can be highly effective. An estimated 87% of individuals in a test group noted their cold sores healed within 6 days of a lysine/herb/zinc treatment.
Although it has shown subjective promise regarding healing and treating cold sores, one major negative factor does exist. Within the noted examples of milk and yogurt, another amino acid also can negate its positive effects.
Known as arginine, this amino acid, found in the body and foods, can serve as a potential agitator of cold sores. Many experts suggest that arginine can cause HSV-1 to thrive and also spread.
The spreading of HSV-1 occurs due to cell replication caused by high arginine intake. Because many foods and beverages contain both lysine and arginine, the two worlds often clash. Milk and yogurt are two of many selections that are caught in the crosshairs.
To combat this potential issue, the U.S. Department of Agriculture created a lysine-to-arginine food ratio chart. The goal is to seek foods that have the widest (highest) lysine-to-arginine ratio. The logic being that limited arginine is less likely to overtake a large amount of lysine, per gram.
Lysine-to-Arginine Reference Info
Noted below are a few milk and yogurt selections:
- 245 grams of skim milk contains 663mg of lysine and 302mg of arginine. (Ratio of 2.195.)
- 244 grams of 2% low-fat milk contains 644mg of lysine and 294mg of arginine. (Ratio of 2.190.)
- 244 grams of whole milk contains 637mg of lysine and 291mg of arginine. (Ratio of 2.189.)
- 227 grams of plain yogurt contains 706mg of lysine and 237mg or arginine. (Ratio of 2.979.) Per the U.S. Department of Agriculture, plain yogurt has the highest lysine to arginine ratio of any conventional food selection. Only margarine is higher with a 3.0 ratio per 14.1 grams.
- 227 grams of low-fat fruit yogurt contains 810mg of lysine and 272mg of arginine. (Ratio of 2.978.)
Another way to include it in your diet without the major threat of arginine is through supplements. Capsule products such as HERP RESCUE can potentially provide relief. This particular remedy incorporates lysine, zinc, vitamin C, and an assortment of cold sore healers.
Supplement instructions and precautions…
- If you experience an outbreak, you are encouraged to take 1,000mg of lysine three times per day. Consumption with a meal is advised.
- Do not take supplements with milk or dairy products.
- Supplements can potentially produce side effects, most notably gastrointestinal issues. You are advised to discontinue if you begin to experience stomach cramps, diarrhea, nausea, etc.
Food to Avoid
Due to the fact that arginine can serve to spread HSV-1, foods that are high in this particular amino acid are discouraged. While the medical community is rather conflicted on this issue, the general idea is that arginine will at the very least be counterproductive.
Listed below are just a few of the notable foods that many experts discourage if you are dealing with a cold sore outbreak.
- Nuts and Seeds
- Raw coconut
Similar to other known cold sore triggers, specific food choices can be problematic. This is why it is important to understand the negative effects of arginine if you are consuming milk and yogurt consumption as a method of prevention.
Lysine Cold Sore Treatments
While foods rich in lysine can potentially provide cold sore relief, several OTC treatments include this amino acid. From chapstick, creams, and ointments, it is now a common ingredient in many medications.
Listed below are just a few of the more notable selections that are available to you.
- Designed to decrease redness, burning, and itching, the Super Lysine Plus Coldstick is a worthy treatment. Capable of moisturizing your lips, this lysine product goes on clear. This selection is ideal if you are in the market for a cold sore healing chapstick.
- If ointments are more your speed, Super Lysine Plus Cold Sore Ointment is available. Providing the same functions as the notable chapstick, this ointment is America’s leading herb/nutrient based HSV-1 treatment. In fact, this product is comprised of 14 total nutrients.
- Containing a host of vitamins, Basic Organics Lysine Lip Ointment can provide cold sore relief. Packaged in a small jar, this selection can easily fit in your pocket, purse, coat, etc. Serving to moisturize the skin, this product can be quite effective if used at the initial onset of symptoms. Basic Organics Ointment also contains camphor which is often used as a cold sore remedy in its own right.
It should be noted that most lysine OTC products can eliminate cold sores within one week. Many times sooner. According to the study mentioned earlier, lysine treatments can eliminate 87% of cold sores within a 7-day window. This is virtually identical to the test group study results noted earlier.
Additionally, it should also be acknowledged that you can apply milk directly to your cold sores. While direct application is largely associated with an OTC, milk can be a direct treatment. Using a cotton ball, milk can be absorbed and then dabbed gently on the problem area. This can potentially provide the same lysine benefits as milk consumption.
Although the conclusion leans more towards inconclusive, products that contain lysine can potentially provide relief. This goes for lysine-based foods and also OTC remedies.
While you are likely to find more positive stories than negative, nothing is foolproof. Because there is no cure for HSV-1, most any option will contain different levels of subjectivity.
The main objective is to find a cold sore treatment that works for you. This will more than likely be found in major brand products that are available on the market.
For most people, cold sores will clear naturally within 2-3 weeks. If a product can reduce that timeframe by half, then you have likely found a winner. Lysine, for this reason alone, is certainly a worthy option. If you naturally enjoy milk and have a favorite yogurt selection, give it a go.
- Harlow Kirsten. L-Lysine Hydrochloride: An Alternative Prophylactic Therapy Reducing the Recurrence Rate of Herpes Labialis. School of Physician Assistant Studies. 2015; Paper 525.
- Singh BB, Udani J, Vinjamury SP, et al. Safety and effectiveness of an L-lysine, zinc, and herbal-based product on the treatment of facial and circumoral herpes. Altern Med Rev. 2005;10(2):123–127.